MacPherson strut vs double wishbone suspension: which is better

A plain comparison of MacPherson strut and double wishbone front suspension: how each controls the wheel, what each demands of the car, and how to choose.

3 min read3 viewsMacPherson strut vs double wishbone suspension: which is better
— · 0 votes
Contents
  1. How a MacPherson strut works
  2. How a double wishbone controls the wheel
  3. Packaging, cost and the alternatives
  4. Questions about strut and wishbone suspension
  5. MacPherson strut vs double wishbone: which is better?
  6. Is a MacPherson strut an independent suspension?
  7. What is the difference between a double wishbone and a double A-arm?
  8. How does multi-link suspension differ from these two?

A MacPherson strut is not automatically worse or better than a double wishbone setup, because the two solve the same job in different ways. The MacPherson strut carries the wheel with one lower arm and a tall damper unit, while the double wishbone uses two arms that hold the wheel between them. Which is better depends on the space the car has, the geometry the designer wants, and how much the buyer values precise camber control. This page explains how each layout works and what it means for the car you drive.

How a MacPherson strut works

A MacPherson strut combines the damper, the coil spring and the top mount into one tall unit that also locates the wheel. The strut bolts to a reinforced strut tower in the body and joins a single lower control arm at the bottom. Because the strut itself sets the kingpin axis, the angle around which the wheel steers, changes to that angle affect steering feel directly. The layout leaves room for a wide engine bay and few parts, which is why it suits transverse engines and tight front ends.

How a double wishbone controls the wheel

A double wishbone suspension holds the wheel between an upper and a lower wishbone, also called A-arms or control arms. The two arms work together to keep the wheel closer to a fixed angle as the body rolls and the wheel moves up and down. That gives the designer finer command of camber control, the tilt of the wheel relative to the road, and of the steering axis. The cost is more parts, more weight, and more space needed around the wheel and above it.

Packaging, cost and the alternatives

Packaging and cost decide the argument more often than pure handling does. A strut needs a tall tower in the body, while wishbones need room above and below the wheel, which constrains engine and cargo layout. Multi-link suspension splits the lower arm into several links for finer tuning at the rear or in premium cars, and a torsion beam keeps a simple twist beam at the back of small cars. Each alternative trades geometry freedom against space, parts count and weight.

Questions about strut and wishbone suspension

MacPherson strut vs double wishbone: which is better?

Neither layout is better in every case, because each suits a different set of priorities. A double wishbone gives stronger camber control and more freedom in front suspension geometry, which helps grip and steering precision. A MacPherson strut saves space and parts, which matters in compact cars with transverse engines. The better choice for a given car is the one the designer can package well.

Is a MacPherson strut an independent suspension?

Yes, a MacPherson strut is an independent suspension because each wheel moves on its own lower arm and strut. One side can rise over a bump without forcing the other side to move. That independence is separate from the layout question, since a double wishbone is independent too. A torsion beam at the rear is the layout where the two sides stay linked.

What is the difference between a double wishbone and a double A-arm?

A double wishbone and a double A-arm name the same layout, so there is no difference between them. Both describe an upper and a lower arm shaped like a letter A that hold the wheel between them. The term wishbone comes from that forked shape, and A-arm describes it from the side. Engineers may favor one word, but the parts and the geometry are the same.

How does multi-link suspension differ from these two?

Multi-link suspension replaces one or both arms with several separate links that each control a different direction of wheel movement. That gives the designer more settings for camber and toe than a single lower arm or a fixed wishbone pair can offer. A multi-link setup costs more and takes more space than a MacPherson strut. Many cars use a strut at the front and a multi-link layout at the rear for that reason.

Latest articles