HMRC approved mileage rates compared with fuel cost per mile

How HMRC approved mileage allowance payments compare with actual fuel cost per mile, what the rate covers, and how to check your own pence per mile figure.

7 min read3 viewsHMRC approved mileage rates compared with fuel cost per mile
— · 0 votes
Contents
  1. What HMRC approved mileage rates actually pay for
  2. How to work out your fuel cost per mile
  3. Where the approved rate and fuel cost diverge
  4. Running a side-by-side comparison of the two figures
  5. Claims, records and company car tax
  6. What a higher or lower fuel cost per mile tells you
  7. Questions about mileage rates and fuel cost
  8. What is the fuel cost per mile for HMRC mileage?
  9. Does the HMRC approved mileage rate only cover fuel?
  10. Why does engine size change the comparison?
  11. Should I keep fuel receipts for a mileage claim?
  12. Is company car tax part of this comparison?

HMRC approved mileage rates are fixed pence per mile allowances for business mileage, not a measurement of what fuel actually costs. Fuel cost per mile is your own calculation from pump price, engine size and fuel type. Comparing the two shows how much of the allowance is left for wear, insurance and other running costs.

  • HMRC approved mileage rates pay a set pence per mile that already includes fuel and running costs.
  • Fuel cost per mile is worked out from the price of fuel and how far your vehicle travels on it.
  • The approved rate is not a fuel rate, so comparing it with fuel cost only shows the fuel share.
  • A larger engine or a thirstier fuel type raises fuel cost per mile and narrows the gap.
  • Keep fuel receipts and mileage logs so an expense claim can be checked later.

What HMRC approved mileage rates actually pay for

HMRC approved mileage allowance payments are a flat amount for each business mile driven in your own vehicle. The rate is meant to cover the whole cost of running the vehicle for work, not fuel alone. It includes wear, servicing, insurance and depreciation alongside fuel.

The rate is set by HMRC and the figure depends on the kind of vehicle and how many business miles you have already claimed. A motorcycle, a van and a car each have their own pence per mile figure, and cars change rate after a set distance. Business mileage means journeys for work that are not your ordinary commute.

Because the allowance is a package, fuel cost per mile is only one slice of it. Comparing the two tells you how much of the approved rate fuel absorbs and how much is left for everything else. HMRC approved mileage rates compared with fuel cost per mile is therefore a comparison of one allowance with one component, not two rival prices.

How to work out your fuel cost per mile

Fuel cost per mile is the amount you spend on fuel to drive one mile in your vehicle. You calculate it from the price you pay per unit of fuel and the distance your vehicle covers on that unit. The result is a pence per mile figure you can set beside the HMRC rate.

Start with a full tank and record the odometer reading. Refill to full again later, note the odometer and the fuel added, then divide the distance by the fuel used to get miles per unit. Multiply that by the pump price to get the cost of one mile.

Fuel type and engine size both move the figure. Diesel, petrol and electricity are measured and priced differently, so the arithmetic differs for each. A larger engine tends to use more fuel per mile, while a smaller one uses less on the same trip.

InputWhat it measuresEffect on pence per mile
Pump price per unitWhat you pay for fuelHigher price raises the cost per mile
Miles per unit of fuelEfficiency of the vehicleMore miles per unit lowers the cost per mile
Fuel typeHow fuel is measured and pricedEach type needs its own calculation
Engine sizeFuel drawn per mileA larger engine tends to raise the cost

Where the approved rate and fuel cost diverge

The approved mileage rate stays the same whatever you pay at the pump on a given day. Fuel cost per mile moves with the price of fuel and with how efficiently you drive. A rise in pump prices widens the gap between the allowance and the fuel share.

A vehicle that returns more miles per unit of fuel leaves more of the approved rate for other costs. A thirstier vehicle eats into the allowance faster through fuel alone. The divergence grows when fuel prices rise and the approved rate stays fixed.

Journeys on electricity need their own cost per mile, because charging is priced and measured differently from liquid fuel. Mixing the two without adjusting the arithmetic gives a misleading comparison. Keep each fuel type in its own line before you set the totals side by side.

Running a side-by-side comparison of the two figures

A side-by-side comparison keeps the approved rate and your fuel cost per mile in separate columns for the same journey. The layout lets you see the fuel share and the remainder at a glance. Your own information, not a generic average, makes the shortlist useful.

Enter the approved pence per mile for your vehicle and business miles first. Add your measured fuel cost per mile beside it, taken from your own refills and odometer readings. A difference column then shows what the allowance leaves after fuel.

Repeat the comparison for each vehicle you are weighing, and keep the same period for all of them. A short-list built this way is easy to audit if a claim is questioned. Store the refill records and odometer notes with each line so the figures can be rebuilt.

Claims, records and company car tax

An expense claim for business mileage rests on the approved rate and on evidence that the miles were driven for work. Mileage logs and fuel receipts support the numbers in the claim. Without records, the comparison has nothing to stand on if it is checked.

Company car tax is separate from the mileage allowance and follows its own rules on the benefit of the vehicle. The approved rate does not settle a company car tax position, and the fuel cost per mile figure does not either. Treat the two questions apart when you build your shortlist.

Where a claim or a tax position is complex, a qualified accountant or tax adviser should check it. The figures here help you organize the comparison, not settle an obligation. Keep the working papers tidy so a specialist can review them quickly.

What a higher or lower fuel cost per mile tells you

A fuel cost per mile that sits well below the approved rate leaves room in the allowance for servicing, tires and depreciation. A figure close to the approved rate means fuel takes nearly all of it. Reading the gap this way turns two numbers into a decision aid.

The gap depends on engine size, fuel type and driving conditions, so it differs from one driver to another. A short urban trip in cold weather uses more fuel per mile than a steady long run. Record the conditions with the figure so the comparison stays honest.

Use the gap to compare vehicles on your shortlist rather than to predict anyone else's costs. A vehicle with a lower fuel cost per mile leaves more of the approved rate for other expenses. Keep the working visible in the table so the reasoning can be followed.

Questions about mileage rates and fuel cost

What is the fuel cost per mile for HMRC mileage?

HMRC does not publish a fuel cost per mile, because the approved mileage rate covers fuel and running costs together. You work out your own fuel cost per mile from pump price and the distance your vehicle covers on a unit of fuel. Set that figure beside the approved rate to see the fuel share.

Does the HMRC approved mileage rate only cover fuel?

No, the HMRC approved mileage allowance payment covers the whole cost of running your own vehicle for business. Fuel is one part, alongside wear, servicing, insurance and depreciation. That is why the approved rate sits above a bare fuel cost per mile for many vehicles.

Why does engine size change the comparison?

Engine size changes how much fuel the vehicle draws for each mile, so it moves the fuel cost per mile. A larger engine tends to use more fuel and narrows the gap to the approved rate. The approved rate itself does not change with engine size.

Should I keep fuel receipts for a mileage claim?

Yes, keep fuel receipts and mileage records for a mileage claim, because they let you rebuild the fuel cost per mile figure. The approved rate pays a flat amount, but records show the business miles were driven. Store them with the comparison so a review is straightforward.

Is company car tax part of this comparison?

No, company car tax sits outside the mileage rate comparison and follows its own rules. The approved mileage rate and your fuel cost per mile do not settle a company car tax position. Keep the tax question separate and ask a qualified adviser about it.

Read next

Latest articles