Decision criteria examples for case analysis
See decision criteria examples for case analysis, learn how to turn a case study into a weighted shortlist, and compare options with criteria you can defend.
Contents
- What a decision criterion contains
- Criteria drawn from the case facts
- Criteria drawn from stakeholder goals
- Examples of criteria by category
- Writing the measure for each criterion
- Scoring options against the criteria
- Testing the criteria for quality
- Presenting the criteria in the write-up
- Questions about case analysis criteria
- What are decision criteria examples for case analysis?
- How many criteria should a case analysis use?
- Where do decision criteria come from in a case study?
- Should criteria be weighted in a case analysis?
- How do you score options against decision criteria?
- What makes a decision criterion weak?
Decision criteria examples for case analysis are the yardsticks a reader applies to the options inside a case study. Each criterion names a quality that matters, states how it will be judged, and lets you compare choices on the same footing. A shortlist built this way shows why one option rises and another falls.
- A criterion needs a name, a measure and a weight before it can compare anything.
- Criteria come from the case facts, the decision maker's goals and the constraints stated in the study.
- Splitting a broad goal into separate criteria keeps the comparison honest.
- Testing each option against every criterion produces a shortlist a reader can audit.
- Stating what a criterion depends on keeps a case analysis free of borrowed figures.
What a decision criterion contains
A decision criterion is a stated test that every option in a case analysis must pass or fail. The name alone is not enough, because two readers can read the same word differently. A usable criterion says what quality it measures and how that quality will be observed.
Each criterion in a case analysis carries three parts: the quality, the measure and the weight. The quality is the goal in plain words, such as cost control or staff safety. The measure describes what evidence would show the quality, and the weight records how much it counts against the others.
Weights turn a list of criteria into a comparison, because they force the analyst to rank priorities rather than treat every goal as equal. A weight can be a simple rank order when the case gives no numbers. The analyst states the reasoning behind the ranking so a reader can challenge it.
Criteria drawn from the case facts
Case facts supply criteria that a reader can trace back to the text. A case study usually states budgets, staffing levels, deadlines and obligations, and each of these points to a test. The analyst writes the criterion so the fact behind it stays visible.
A budget ceiling becomes a criterion about affordability, measured against the funds the case names. A staffing limit becomes a criterion about workload, measured by the hours the existing team can absorb. A deadline becomes a criterion about timing, measured by what can be ready within the stated window.
Facts also rule criteria out, because an option that breaks a stated limit cannot win on other grounds. The analyst records such a limit as a pass or fail gate rather than a scored criterion. Gates narrow the field before scoring begins and keep the shortlist realistic.
Criteria drawn from stakeholder goals
Stakeholder goals give a case analysis criteria that the numbers alone cannot supply. Owners, employees, customers and regulators each hold a different view of what success looks like. The analyst turns each stated goal into a criterion with a measure attached.
A goal such as fair treatment of staff becomes a criterion about how an option affects working conditions. A goal such as customer trust becomes a criterion about transparency and reliability. The measure for each goal describes the evidence a reader would accept, not a feeling about the option.
Where goals conflict, the analyst names the conflict instead of hiding it inside one blended score. Two separate criteria can carry opposite weights, which shows the trade-off openly. A reader can then see which option serves which group and judge the balance.
Examples of criteria by category
Criteria fall into a few broad categories, and a balanced case analysis draws from more than one. Financial, operational, legal, ethical and strategic tests each catch problems the others miss. Naming the category helps a reader check that nothing important is absent.
A financial criterion might measure the cost to run an option against the funds available. An operational criterion might measure whether the current team can deliver the work. A legal criterion checks that an option fits the rules that bind the organization in the case.
An ethical criterion measures the effect on people who have no voice in the decision. A strategic criterion measures how well an option fits the long-term direction the case describes. Using examples from several categories stops one type of concern from crowding out the rest.
- Cost: what the option takes to run against the funds available
- Capacity: whether the team and equipment can carry the work
- Compliance: whether the option fits the rules that bind the organization
- Safety: the risk an option creates for people and property
- Fairness: how the option treats groups with less power
- Fit: how well the option serves the stated long-term direction
Writing the measure for each criterion
The measure is what separates a real criterion from a slogan. A decision criterion in case analysis must say what evidence would show the quality is present. The analyst writes the measure as a plain description of the observation, not as a number pulled from outside the case.
A measure for delivery speed could be the number of steps an option adds to a process the case describes. A measure for resilience could be how many single points of failure the option leaves. A measure for transparency could be how much of the process a customer can see.
Where a figure such as a payback period or a failure rate matters, the analysis names what that figure depends on. The reader is told which assumption drives the number rather than handed a borrowed statistic. That keeps the case analysis tied to its own facts.
Scoring options against the criteria
Scoring turns a set of criteria into a ranked shortlist. The analyst gives each option a mark on each criterion, using a scale the case supports, such as weak, adequate or strong. The mark rests on the evidence the measure describes.
A table with criteria as rows and options as columns lets a reader follow the comparison in one view. Marks can be words or simple points, as long as the same scale applies to every option. The weight for each row then shows which differences matter most.
After scoring, the analyst checks whether any option fails a gate that was set from case facts. An option that fails a gate leaves the shortlist regardless of its total. The remaining options are ranked by weighted score, and the analysis explains the gap between the top two.
| Criterion | What the measure observes | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Cost to run | Ongoing expense against available funds | High |
| Capacity | Work the current team can absorb | High |
| Compliance | Fit with the rules named in the case | Gate |
| Safety | Risk to people and property | Gate |
| Strategic fit | Alignment with the stated direction | Medium |
Testing the criteria for quality
A sound criterion set passes a few checks before it drives any decision. Each criterion should measure one quality, not two bundled together. The whole set should cover the goals the case states without doubling them.
Two criteria that measure the same quality add weight to one concern without saying so. The analyst merges such pairs or drops the weaker one. A criterion with no measure cannot be scored, so it either gains a measure or leaves the list.
Criteria should also separate the options, since a test every option passes tells the reader nothing. The analyst checks whether the marks actually differ across the field. A criterion that cannot separate options may still stand as a gate, but it does not belong in the weighted score.
Presenting the criteria in the write-up
The write-up shows the criteria before it shows the verdict, so a reader can follow the reasoning. The analyst lists each decision criterion with its category, measure and weight in one place. Options then appear against that frame rather than in a separate argument.
Sensitivity matters in the write-up, because a weight is a judgment and a reader may hold it differently. The analyst notes which criteria, if weighted higher or lower, would change the ranking. That note shows how firm the shortlist is and where the real trade-off sits.
The conclusion names the criteria that decided the case and the options they favor. A reader should be able to quote any single criterion and understand what it tested. Clear labels and consistent scales make the case analysis easy to audit and reuse.
Questions about case analysis criteria
What are decision criteria examples for case analysis?
Decision criteria examples for case analysis are stated tests such as cost to run, capacity, compliance, safety and strategic fit. Each example pairs a quality with a measure and a weight. The analyst applies them to every option so the options can be compared on the same terms.
How many criteria should a case analysis use?
A case analysis works with a small set of criteria that covers the goals the case states without repeating them. Too few criteria hide a trade-off, and too many blur the ranking. The right number depends on how many distinct goals and constraints the case study names.
Where do decision criteria come from in a case study?
Decision criteria in a case study come from the stated facts and the goals of the stakeholders. Budgets, staffing limits, deadlines and rules supply gates and scored tests. The goals of owners, employees, customers and regulators supply the qualitative criteria.
Should criteria be weighted in a case analysis?
Yes, weighting criteria makes the priorities behind a decision visible. A weight forces the analyst to rank goals instead of treating each as equal. Simple rank orders work when the case gives no numbers, provided the reasoning is stated.
How do you score options against decision criteria?
Scoring options means giving each one a mark on each criterion, using a single scale such as weak, adequate or strong. The marks rest on the evidence named in the measure. Weighted totals then rank the options, and any failed gate removes an option first.
What makes a decision criterion weak?
A weak decision criterion measures two qualities at once or carries no measure at all. A criterion that every option passes also adds little to a weighted score. The analyst fixes a weak criterion by splitting it, adding a measure, or moving it to a gate.