# Common mistakes when choosing decision criteria

See which errors weaken a comparison, from vague and redundant criteria to missing ones, and how to fix each before you build your shortlist.

Mistakes when choosing decision criteria make a comparison measure the wrong things about each option. The four main errors are vague criteria, too many criteria, redundant criteria and missing criteria. Each error distorts a shortlist in its own way and calls for a different fix. Spotting them early keeps your side-by-side comparison honest and easy to read. 

## Vague criteria hide real differences 

Vague criteria are factors like 'quality' or 'value' that no two people would score the same way. A vague criterion cannot be checked against a listing, so ratings drift with mood. Rewrite each one as something you can observe, such as material, size or included parts. A clear criterion lets you score two options and explain the difference to someone else. 

## Too many and repeated criteria skew scores 

Too many criteria spread your attention thin and let minor factors outweigh the ones that matter. Redundant criteria, which measure the same thing under two names, count one strength twice. Screen size and display area, for example, should merge into a single line. Keep the criteria you would actually use to reject an option, then drop the rest. 

## How to catch mistakes in choosing criteria 

Missing criteria are needs you hold but never wrote down, such as delivery terms or upkeep. A missing criterion often shows up late, when an option that scores well still feels wrong. Ask what would make you return or regret a purchase, then add that factor to the list. Test the final set on two options you already know well to see whether the ranking makes sense. 

## Questions about choosing decision criteria 

### How many decision criteria should I use? 

No fixed number of decision criteria suits every purchase, because the right count depends on the decision. A small, everyday purchase needs only a few factors that separate the options. A complex purchase may need more, provided each criterion changes which option wins. If a criterion never changes the ranking, remove it from the list. 

### Should I weight some criteria more than others? 

Yes, weighting criteria helps when some factors matter more to you than others. Weighting means giving each criterion a share of importance before you score any option. Set the weights first, so the scores of a favorite listing cannot sway them. Keep the weights simple enough that you can explain each one in plain words. 

### What is the difference between a must-have and a nice-to-have criterion? 

A must-have criterion rules out any option that fails it, while a nice-to-have adds points. Treat must-haves as filters applied before scoring, not as heavily weighted factors. Mixing the two types lets a strong score on extras hide a missing essential. 

### Can I change my criteria after I start comparing? 

Yes, you can change decision criteria during a comparison when you learn something new about your needs. Rescore every option against the revised list, not only the ones you are still viewing. Be wary of changing criteria just to make a favorite option come out on top. Note the reason for each change so the shortlist stays easy to understand later.
